Not that it really had much competition (that we know of, anyway) but this Darth Vader toothpick dispenser, in which Vader grabs each new toothpick from inside his cape and brandishes it like a lightsaber, has instantly claimed the title of the Best Toothpick Dispenser of All Time. Currently, it's only available in Japan, which is a great injustice. It might be worth moving to Japan to get one.
• Every Star Wars Fan Is Going to Want This Stupid Darth Vader Toothpick Dispenser [Toyland]