Restored 1756 Martha’s Vineyard farmhouse asks $2.25M

Have a nomination for a jaw-dropping listing that would make a mighty fine House of the Day? Get thee to the tipline and send us your suggestions. We’d love to see what you’ve got.

Location: West Tisbury, Massachusetts

Price: $2,250,000

’Tis the season for Martha’s Vineyard, the bucolic Massachusetts island retreat with beautiful small towns, beaches, and farmland. And here’s a chance to own a piece of it: This restored 1756 farmhouse in the town of West Tisbury is on the market for a cool $2.25M.

Though it looks like a modest Cape Cod house from the front, the idyllic home actually covers 4,400 square feet, spread over the three-bedroom main residence, a separate one-bedroom apartment, and a “bunk house” for overflow guests.

The interior offers intimate farmhouse vibes, with sensible updates like new windows marble countertops, and stainless steel appliances. Old fireplace lovers, rejoice: A handful of brick fireplaces help the home retain its antique origins.

The property, located at 271 Indian Hill Road, sits on one and a half acres, which includes a garden, custom tree house, tree swing, and a grove of cedar, walnut, and more.