clock menu more-arrow no yes

The 18 Essential Cape and Islands Hotels, November 2014

View as Map

In the latest release of Curbed's Hotel 18 map, we're once again tackling the question, "Where should I stay on the Cape and Islands?" In an attempt to answer that off-season conundrum, we've put together an eclectic assortment of options: from just over the bridge to the edge of the continent; from low-key to luxury; and from wee B&Bs to mega resorts. Most of these Cape Cod, Martha's Vineyard and Nantucket accommodations are open year-round, but a few have limited winter availability so do keep that in mind. We'll be updating the map again in due time, so if you have a favorite that wasn't included, please mention it in the comments or tip us for next time.

Read More

1. The Dan'l Webster Inn & Spa

Copy Link
149 Main St
Sandwich, MA 02563
(508) 888-3622
Visit Website

Located in the center of the oldest town on Cape Cod, this Sandwich inn has offered lodging for over 300 years. Each of the 48 guest rooms and suites of The Dan'l Webster Inn is appointed with period furnishings and the property includes and outdoor pool plus five distinctive dining rooms.

2. Belfry Inn and Bistro

Copy Link
6 Jarves Street
Sandwich, MA 02563
(508) 888-8550
Visit Website

Transformed from a neglected 1872 Victorian home, a former Catholic Church and a circa 1830 Federal-style building, the Belfry Inn and Bistro has been a charming bed and breakfast in historic Sandwich Village since opening in 1995. The 22 romantic guest rooms, spa services and restaurant are divided between The Painted Lady, The Abbey and The Village House.

3. Sea Crest Beach Hotel

Copy Link
350 Quaker Rd
North Falmouth, MA 02556
(508) 540-9400
Visit Website

The recently renovated Sea Crest Beach hotel features 263 guest rooms and suites, indoor and outdoor saline pools, and one of the Cape's largest conference facilities. The restaurant, Red's, is named after the hotel's previous owner and Celtic's legend Red Auerbach.

4. Cape Codder Resort & Spa

Copy Link
1225 Iyannough Rd
Hyannis, MA 02601
(508) 771-3000

Rumored to be where Oprah and her BFF Gayle stayed while in town for Eunice Kennedy Shriver's funeral (and subsequently, the location of Pie-Gate) the Cape Codder is best known for its wicked awesome Indoor Wave Pool and family-friendly vibe.

5. Bayside Resort Indoor Pool

Copy Link
225 Massachusetts 28
West Yarmouth, MA 02673

This solar powered resort overlooks Lewis Bay and provides good value for immaculately clean and comfortable lodging.

6. The Inn at Cape Cod

Copy Link
4 Summer Street
Yarmouth Port, MA 02675
800-850-7301

This classic New England bed and breakfast inn has been compared to a small boutique hotel. Opened in 1830 as the Sears Hotel, The Inn at Cape Cod has seven luxury rooms and suites, all recently remodeled.

7. Cape Cod Irish Village

Copy Link
822 Massachusetts 28, S.
Yarmouth, MA 02664
(508) 771-0100

"The best of Ireland on Cape Cod" since 1976, The Irish Village is a destination in itself. The 130 mini-suites are moderately priced and the property features indoor and outdoor pools, a restaurant as well as a pub offering traditional Irish entertainment.

8. The Platinum Pebble Boutique Inn

Copy Link
186 Belmont Road
West Harwich, MA 02671
(508) 432-7766
Visit Website

Behold, the old-meets-new in Harwich. A classic looking exterior (hello, 1870s sea captain's home) and modern interior (hello, luxury linens and eco-friendly towels) help this unique, award-winning bed and breakfast stand out in the crowd.

9. Ocean Edge Resort & Golf Club

Copy Link
2907 Main St
Brewster, MA 02631

Both the Mansion side and the Villages of the Ocean Edge Resort and Golf Club have been offering casual elegance and endless amenities since 1986.

10. Chatham Bars Inn

Copy Link
297 Shore Road
Chatham, MA 02633

The iconic Chatham Bars Inn has been in operation since 1914. The luxury resort sits on 25 acres on a bluff overlooking the Atlantic Ocean and is chock full of amenities, including: a state-of-the-art fitness center, clay tennis courts, and The Spa with individual suites featuring hydrotherapy tubs, saunas, steam showers, and the Chatham Bars Inn signature fireplace.

11. Orleans Inn

Copy Link
3 Old County Rd
Orleans, MA 02653

Overlooking Town Cove, this centrally-located historic waterfront inn features 11 simple guest rooms, modern amenities, a year-round restaurant, and bar.

12. Land's End Inn

Copy Link
22 Commercial Street
Provincetown, MA 02657
(508) 487-0706
Visit Website

This West End inn has 18 luxurious, themed guest rooms and ocean views for days. The hilltop location is off the beaten path, yet close enough to walk to PTown activities.

13. Crowne Point Historic Inn and Spa

Copy Link
82 Bradford St
Provincetown, MA

This 40-room landmark boutique hotel resides in a classic 140-year old Cape Cod Sea Captain's estate. The six architecturally restored buildings include a main mansion, award-winning day spa and fine dining restaurant.

14. Provincetown Inn

Copy Link
1 Commercial St
Provincetown, MA 02657
(508) 487-9500

Literally located on the tip of Cape Cod with a one-of-a-kind Olympic sized pool in the shape of a pilgrim's hat, the Provincetown Inn is a true classic. The resort is older, but the edge-of-the-continent location makes for a relatively good value.

15. Mansion House Inn

Copy Link
9 Main Street
Vineyard Haven, MA

Established in 1791 and rebuilt in 2003, the guest rooms, spa and health club at the Mansion House feature 21st century amenities. There's a harbor viewing cupola and a limited number of rooms are pet friendly.

16. Harbor View Hotel

Copy Link
131 North Water Street
Edgartown, MA 02539

The 114 "casually sophisticated, well-appointed" guest rooms and suites in the Harbor View Hotel are divided between the historic hotel, the Governor Mayhew Building and in Cottages. Located at the edge of town, the property features gorgeous water views and walkability.

17. The Nantucket Hotel

Copy Link
77 Easton St
Nantucket, MA 02554
(508) 310-1734

Established in 1871, The Nantucket Hotel & Resort was completely renovated by new owners in 2012, retaining the traditional Nantucket feel while adding a dash of world class beachy modern. The year-round resort is located in-town and within walking distance of beaches, shopping, restaurants, and the harbor.

18. Seven Sea Street Inn

Copy Link
7 Sea Street
Nantucket, MA 02554

This red oak post-and-beam charmer was "designed and constructed with an authentic Nantucket ambiance in mind." The bed and breakfast offers walkability and rates that are "neither the highest nor the lowest to be found on Nantucket Island."

1. The Dan'l Webster Inn & Spa

149 Main St, Sandwich, MA 02563

Located in the center of the oldest town on Cape Cod, this Sandwich inn has offered lodging for over 300 years. Each of the 48 guest rooms and suites of The Dan'l Webster Inn is appointed with period furnishings and the property includes and outdoor pool plus five distinctive dining rooms.

149 Main St
Sandwich, MA 02563

2. Belfry Inn and Bistro

6 Jarves Street, Sandwich, MA 02563

Transformed from a neglected 1872 Victorian home, a former Catholic Church and a circa 1830 Federal-style building, the Belfry Inn and Bistro has been a charming bed and breakfast in historic Sandwich Village since opening in 1995. The 22 romantic guest rooms, spa services and restaurant are divided between The Painted Lady, The Abbey and The Village House.

6 Jarves Street
Sandwich, MA 02563

3. Sea Crest Beach Hotel

350 Quaker Rd, North Falmouth, MA 02556

The recently renovated Sea Crest Beach hotel features 263 guest rooms and suites, indoor and outdoor saline pools, and one of the Cape's largest conference facilities. The restaurant, Red's, is named after the hotel's previous owner and Celtic's legend Red Auerbach.

350 Quaker Rd
North Falmouth, MA 02556

4. Cape Codder Resort & Spa

1225 Iyannough Rd, Hyannis, MA 02601

Rumored to be where Oprah and her BFF Gayle stayed while in town for Eunice Kennedy Shriver's funeral (and subsequently, the location of Pie-Gate) the Cape Codder is best known for its wicked awesome Indoor Wave Pool and family-friendly vibe.

1225 Iyannough Rd
Hyannis, MA 02601

5. Bayside Resort Indoor Pool

225 Massachusetts 28, West Yarmouth, MA 02673

This solar powered resort overlooks Lewis Bay and provides good value for immaculately clean and comfortable lodging.

225 Massachusetts 28
West Yarmouth, MA 02673

6. The Inn at Cape Cod

4 Summer Street, Yarmouth Port, MA 02675

This classic New England bed and breakfast inn has been compared to a small boutique hotel. Opened in 1830 as the Sears Hotel, The Inn at Cape Cod has seven luxury rooms and suites, all recently remodeled.

4 Summer Street
Yarmouth Port, MA 02675

7. Cape Cod Irish Village

822 Massachusetts 28, S., Yarmouth, MA 02664

"The best of Ireland on Cape Cod" since 1976, The Irish Village is a destination in itself. The 130 mini-suites are moderately priced and the property features indoor and outdoor pools, a restaurant as well as a pub offering traditional Irish entertainment.

822 Massachusetts 28, S.
Yarmouth, MA 02664

8. The Platinum Pebble Boutique Inn

186 Belmont Road, West Harwich, MA 02671

Behold, the old-meets-new in Harwich. A classic looking exterior (hello, 1870s sea captain's home) and modern interior (hello, luxury linens and eco-friendly towels) help this unique, award-winning bed and breakfast stand out in the crowd.

186 Belmont Road
West Harwich, MA 02671

9. Ocean Edge Resort & Golf Club

2907 Main St, Brewster, MA 02631

Both the Mansion side and the Villages of the Ocean Edge Resort and Golf Club have been offering casual elegance and endless amenities since 1986.

2907 Main St
Brewster, MA 02631

10. Chatham Bars Inn

297 Shore Road, Chatham, MA 02633

The iconic Chatham Bars Inn has been in operation since 1914. The luxury resort sits on 25 acres on a bluff overlooking the Atlantic Ocean and is chock full of amenities, including: a state-of-the-art fitness center, clay tennis courts, and The Spa with individual suites featuring hydrotherapy tubs, saunas, steam showers, and the Chatham Bars Inn signature fireplace.

297 Shore Road
Chatham, MA 02633

11. Orleans Inn

3 Old County Rd, Orleans, MA 02653

Overlooking Town Cove, this centrally-located historic waterfront inn features 11 simple guest rooms, modern amenities, a year-round restaurant, and bar.

3 Old County Rd
Orleans, MA 02653

12. Land's End Inn

22 Commercial Street, Provincetown, MA 02657

This West End inn has 18 luxurious, themed guest rooms and ocean views for days. The hilltop location is off the beaten path, yet close enough to walk to PTown activities.

22 Commercial Street
Provincetown, MA 02657

13. Crowne Point Historic Inn and Spa

82 Bradford St, Provincetown, MA

This 40-room landmark boutique hotel resides in a classic 140-year old Cape Cod Sea Captain's estate. The six architecturally restored buildings include a main mansion, award-winning day spa and fine dining restaurant.

82 Bradford St
Provincetown, MA

14. Provincetown Inn

1 Commercial St, Provincetown, MA 02657

Literally located on the tip of Cape Cod with a one-of-a-kind Olympic sized pool in the shape of a pilgrim's hat, the Provincetown Inn is a true classic. The resort is older, but the edge-of-the-continent location makes for a relatively good value.

1 Commercial St
Provincetown, MA 02657

15. Mansion House Inn

9 Main Street, Vineyard Haven, MA

Established in 1791 and rebuilt in 2003, the guest rooms, spa and health club at the Mansion House feature 21st century amenities. There's a harbor viewing cupola and a limited number of rooms are pet friendly.

9 Main Street
Vineyard Haven, MA

16. Harbor View Hotel

131 North Water Street, Edgartown, MA 02539

The 114 "casually sophisticated, well-appointed" guest rooms and suites in the Harbor View Hotel are divided between the historic hotel, the Governor Mayhew Building and in Cottages. Located at the edge of town, the property features gorgeous water views and walkability.

131 North Water Street
Edgartown, MA 02539

17. The Nantucket Hotel

77 Easton St, Nantucket, MA 02554

Established in 1871, The Nantucket Hotel & Resort was completely renovated by new owners in 2012, retaining the traditional Nantucket feel while adding a dash of world class beachy modern. The year-round resort is located in-town and within walking distance of beaches, shopping, restaurants, and the harbor.

77 Easton St
Nantucket, MA 02554

18. Seven Sea Street Inn

7 Sea Street, Nantucket, MA 02554

This red oak post-and-beam charmer was "designed and constructed with an authentic Nantucket ambiance in mind." The bed and breakfast offers walkability and rates that are "neither the highest nor the lowest to be found on Nantucket Island."

7 Sea Street
Nantucket, MA 02554